Reaching Evangelical Christians in the Bible Belt
October 2018 – Christ at the Checkpoint conferences have been held at Bethlehem Bible College in the West Bank since 2010. They have the unique mission of reaching out to evangelical Christians, an often negelected constiuency in Israel/Palestine organizing.
For the first tme, Christians in the United States, specifically in the so-called American “Bible belt,” were offered a similar opportunity, on May 15-18, 2018 in Oklahoma City, OK. The event was attended by over 150 people from across the country, including numerous United Methodists, as well as many from other Christian denominations, other religions, and some who are non-affiliated.
UMKR WAS ALL-IN
UMKR provided multi-faceted support for this ground-breaking conference,
with funding, organizing and promotion, and other resources. Rev. Alex Awad
– retired Palestinian clergy and UMC missionary, and UMKR Steering Committee
member – was one of the major organizers and a keynote speaker at the opening
United Methodists from many locations came to CATCUSA, including
John Wagner and Andrea Whitmore, UMKR Co-chairs (Ohio and Kansas),
Lisa Bender, chair of UMKR’s Boycott & Divestment Committee (Pennsylvania),
Rev. Kristen Brown, UMC Missionary in Israel/Palestine (Jerusalem), J.R. Atkins, seminary student at Emory (Atlanta, GA) and President of Something Different Ministries, and Rev. Connie Barnett, Pastor at St. Luke's Asbury UMC (Oklahoma City, OK).
The event was organized by the
United Methodist Oklahoma Conference, and
yet it drew a significant turnout from other
Christian denominations, other religions, and
some who identified as non-affiliated.
UMKR hosted a display table, which was in the
same room as the plenary sessions, so there was
time between talks for people to visit and pick up
copies of UMKR’s popular Quick Facts series
(check them out here). UMKR also provided
copies of the Kairos Palestine document to
every person who attended the conference.
Among the many concurrent workshops, UMKR led two
sessions during the 4-day conference, focusing on the UMKR
movement within the UMC. Attendees included UM young
adults and a UMC pastor, who were excited about getting
involved in UMKR.
COUNTERING CHRISTIAN ZIONISM
The biggest focus of this conference was countering the theology of
Christian Zionism; most of Wednesday the 17th was spent on that subject.
Organizers invited two representatives of what they called "New Christian
Zionism,” who participated in a discussion with Dr. Stephen Sizer and
Rev. Munther Isaac. Sizer is one of the world’s leading authors on the flaws
and pitfalls of Christian Zionim, and Isaac is a Palestinian Christian
theologian, faculty in biblical studies at Bethlehem Bible College, pastor
of the Evangelical Lutheran Christmas Church in Bethlehem, and Director
of the Christ at the Checkpoint conferences in Bethlehem.
The core of the debate centered on interpretations of scripture on
God’s promise to Abraham regarding the Promised Land, specifically
whether the Hebrew Testamen covenant is still in effect today or
Jesus’ covenant has changed that and and whether the latter includes
and applies to all of the world’s people.
One of the most intriguing points was made during a Q and A session,
when Jonathan Kuttab, a human rights attorney and leading Palestinian
activist, pressed the Christian Zionists spokesperson to say if he, as a
Palestinian Christian, has equality with the Jewish people. The Christian
Zionist who responded hedged around that word and said he had
respect for Jonathan, but would not say he was equal.
Other memorable moments reported by our Steering Committee members:
Grace Zoughbi and Michael Arteen: Grace, faculty at Bethlehem
Bible College, was a featured speaker at this event. Michael is a
GBGM (UMC) missionary who, after serving at Bethlehem Bible
College for a time, has not been able to get his visa renewed by Israel.
He currently lives in Egypt, while Grace is in Bethlehem, so this
young couple is kept apart by Israeli policies. The conference body
laid hands on them and prayed for Michael's visa to come through,
and their emotion was evident.
Archbishop Elias Chacour, an amazing story-teller,
described the moving history of his family's removal from
their home during the Nakkba and of starting his ministry in
Ibilin, northern Israel. [See and hear Chacour’s story in the
acclaimed film: “The Stones Cry Out:
Voices of Palestinian Christians]
Dr. Gary Burge led excellent morning Bible studies at this event.
Burge teaches the New Testament at Calvin Theological
Seminary and serves on the planning team for CATC in Bethlehem.
Dr. Mae Elise Cannon, Executive Director of Churches for
Middle East Peace (CMEP), was inspiring in her leading role as
an evangelical Christian woman who supports Palestinian rights
in the political hotbed that is Washington DC.
After the event, Andrea Whitmore recalls: “The addresses at the conference were more inspiring than I can possibly convey, extraordinary speakers giving extraordinary talks.”
ISRAELI AND AMERICAN JEWISH SPEAKERS
Rabbi Michael Davis keynoted the closing plenary session of the conference, speaking on “What Can Christians & Jews Do Together to Work for Peace?” Davis grew up in Israel where he trained at leading rabbinical seminaries; he has served the Jewish community in Chicago since 1995. He founded the Open Hillel Rabbinical Council in 2014, and for three years directed the Holocaust Memorial Day programming at the Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center.
Mark Braverman shared a plenary session with Bob Roberts, where they addressed “Jewish and Christian Attitudes toward the Conflict. Braverman is a prominent Jewish-American author on Israel/Palestine and program director of Kairos USA; Roberts is founding pastor of the popular
non-denominational Northwood Church in Texas and an outspoken supporter for interfaith work.
CATCUSA , IN THEIR OWN WORDS
The conference website says this conference is “for anyone interested in the issues regarding the conflict or desires to learn from and connect with brothers and sisters in the Land. The event is not intended to get participants to take sides for or against any group or government or people, but to genuinely explore how Jesus can be lifted up as the hope of the world.” In fulfillment of that mission, CATC brought over a dozen speakers from Palestine to the U.S. - see all the speakers here.
Rev. Darrell Cates, Director of Conference and Church Relations at The Oklahoma United Methodist Foundation is the Director of CATCUSA: “In more than twenty years of leading groups to experience the land of the Bible, I’ve discovered a community of Jesus followers seeking to live out a vital and faithful witness who are largely discounted and forgotten. Christ at the Checkpoint USA is an effort to tell their story.”
CONTROVERSY AND PERSONAL CHALLENGES
Such events in the U.S. are always potential targets of controversy, hence the need for a notable police presence inside and outside the Reed Conference Center. There was public antagonism directed at the conference, from Jewish News Service and some local Jewish leaders, who accused the event of having an anti-Semitic message and making a “concerted effort to turn Middle America away from supporting Israel.
Some conference speakers noted that they had been challenged for participating in CATCUSA. One of those was retired Bishop Robert E. Hayes, who served as bishop of the UMC Oklahoma Conference for 12 years. Hayes said he was “rebuked” by one person for being a speaker at the conference. Hayes said: “This week I’ve had some question why I should even be here. To them, I say, ‘Sometimes it’s good to be the bishop.’”
Hayes described the intersections between the lives of Palestinian Christians today and his experiences as an African American in the 1960s, incorporating his knowledge of black liberation theology and his visits to Israel/Palestine. “I don’t have to be Palestinian to know how it feels to be treated like that, because I experienced it in another sense. It was like a page ripped from the 1960s,” he said. “And I don’t know if it will be in my lifetime, but I believe that wall will come down. Maybe in my grandchildren’s lifetime, those checkpoints will be no more.”
See more about CATCUSA and the remarkable lineup of speakers: https://catcusa.com/
Find videos of many of these speakers at the website of CATC in Bethlehem: https://christatthecheckpoint.bethbc.edu/
Some information for this report was drawn from an article at Religion News Service: https://religionnews.com/2018/10/23/palestinian-christian-israel/
News & Analysis UMKR News & Action Alerts
for our work to continue.
UMKR needs your support
General Conference 2020 has been
scheduled for Aug-Sept 2022. Our justice legislation is still vital & needs
YOUR support! LEARN MORE:
🔶 See New Items 🔴 New on our site